govt.fyi
NY State Legislature · S5170-2025 · Vetoed

Relates to permitting a plaintiff to recover directly against a third party defendant found to be liable in certain actions

Introduced
Moved
Reached a final decision
Vetoed
Derived from the official record below.

Officially: “Relates to permitting a plaintiff to recover directly against a third party defendant found to be liable in certain actions Read the full text

Senate

What it does

Permits a plaintiff to recover directly against a third party defendant found to be liable to the defendant in certain actions.
Summary from the sponsor's memo in the official legislative record, shown verbatim. Not legal advice.

Where it is

REFERRED TO JUDICIARY · Feb 19, 2025

Senate

COMMITTEE DISCHARGED AND COMMITTED TO RULES · Jun 10, 2025

Senate

ORDERED TO THIRD READING CAL.1744 · Jun 10, 2025

Senate

PASSED SENATE · Jun 10, 2025

Senate

DELIVERED TO ASSEMBLY · Jun 10, 2025

Senate

REFERRED TO JUDICIARY · Jun 10, 2025

Assembly

SUBSTITUTED FOR A3351 · Jun 17, 2025

Assembly

ORDERED TO THIRD READING RULES CAL.856 · Jun 17, 2025

Assembly

PASSED ASSEMBLY · Jun 17, 2025

Assembly

RETURNED TO SENATE · Jun 17, 2025

Assembly

DELIVERED TO GOVERNOR · Dec 8, 2025

Senate

VETOED MEMO.146 · Dec 19, 2025

Senate

Why the Governor vetoed it

VETO MESSAGE - No. 146 TO THE SENATE: I am returning herewith, without my approval, the following bill: Senate Bill Number 5170, entitled: "AN ACT to amend the civil practice law and rules, in relation to permitting a plaintiff to recover against a third party defendant in certain cases" NOT APPROVED This bill amends the Civil Procedure Law and Rules to allow an injured plaintiff to directly recover from a third-party defendant on a judgment for contribution or indemnification when the defendant/third- party plaintiff fails to satisfy the underlying judgment upon which the contribution or indemnification is based. In particular, the bill would overturn Court of Appeals precedent and longstanding State policy by requiring workers' compensation insurance to pay for the unsatisfied amount of any judgment obtained by an injured worker in applicable cases. I support protecting workers and com...
Veto message no. 146, quoted verbatim from the official record, signed KATHY HOCHUL. The full message is on the official bill page.

The numbers

1
sponsor on the bill

Sponsors

James Skoufis

Recorded votes

Recorded voteSenate · 2025-06-10 · EXC 5, NAY 18, AYE 40
Recorded voteSenate · 2025-06-10 · EXC 2, AYEWR 2, NAY 5, AYE 12
Roll-call results shown verbatim from the New York legislature’s records. A result reflects that roll call’s own motion, not the bill’s overall outcome.

Who is lobbying on this

GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES INSURANCE COMPANY (GEICO)via GOVERNMENT EMPLOYEES INSURANCE COMPANY (GEICO)
7 filings
LAWSUIT REFORM ALLIANCE OF NEW YORK, INC.via LAWSUIT REFORM ALLIANCE OF NEW YORK, INC.
7 filings
NEW YORK STATE AFL-CIOvia NEW YORK STATE AFL-CIO
5 filings
ACADIA INSURANCE GROUP, LLCvia BARRETT ASSOCIATES
4 filings
NEW YORK CENTRAL MUTUAL FIRE INSURANCE COMPANY (NY)via BARRETT ASSOCIATES
4 filings
TRIAL LAWYERS ASSOCIATION (NYS)via RIDDETT ASSOCIATES INC
4 filings
AMERICAN PROPERTY CASUALTY INSURANCE ASSOCIATIONvia AMERICAN PROPERTY CASUALTY INSURANCE ASSOCIATION
3 filings
MEDICAL SOCIETY OF THE STATE OF NYvia MEDICAL SOCIETY OF THE STATE OF NY
3 filings
From 67 filings in New York State lobbying disclosures (COELIG), via data.ny.gov, naming this bill (2025 to 2026). Filings are self-reported by lobbying firms and show who is paid to influence this bill. They do not say which side, or whether it worked.
Nothing on this page shows why any vote was cast. Recorded votes and lobbying filings are separate official records, self-reported by different parties, and neither explains the other.
Every fact on this page links to its source, starting with the official bill record. Last action: Vetoed (Dec 19, 2025).